PHOTO FINISH
The Nokia 8 and Google
Pixel 2 both touted as camera phones face stiff competition from the new
Apple iPhones, Samsung Galaxy Notes and the OnePluses. Nokia wants to put its
Windows Phone days behind it and now hopes to woo its old faithfuls with new
Android devices, while Google has been trying--ever since its Nexus
smartphones--to lure back its old flock on the promise of OS updates, and the
strength of its sterling cameras. Ashutosh Desai puts the Nokia 8 and Google
Pixel 2 XL through their paces to tell you if they are worth the hype and your
money...
NOKIA 8
The Nokia 8 is an all-round
performer. You get the latest processing hardware, its cameras are capable of
great photos, while videos are further enhanced by its spatial audio recording
technology. Its hybrid SIM slot means you can add extra storage space with a
memory card. Plus, you are assured the Android Oreo update, whenever available.
If you are a Nokia
loyalist, you won't be disappointed with this handset, but we recommend you
check alternatives--like OnePlus 5 and Honor 8 Pro--before putting your money
down for this one.
BUILD & DESIGN:
The Nokia 8 boasts of a
polished aluminium unibody , with sturdy plastic edges at the top and bottom of
the phone to conceal its antennae. The device carries an IP54 rating, which
means it is resistant to dust particles and is splash proof. This does not mean
that the handset will survive a dunk in water, but its construction provides
you with some insurance against water and liquid damage.
Up front, you get a
5.3-inch Gorilla Glass 5 display and a capacitive home button with backlit
navigation controls on either side. The home button also doubles up as a
fingerprint sensor for added security . This worked flawlessly , time after
time, to unlock the device.
Overall, this smartphone
feels solid to hold, but when it comes to design it still seems
underwhelming, especially since many devices, which cost half as much, look
almost identical.
TOUCHSCREEN DISPLAY:
The Nokia 8's display is
bright, and is legible even in direct sunlight. It is capable of rendering
crisp text and sharp visuals with natural colours. Nokia doesn't allow you to
customise screen colour profiles, but the handset's default output and
excellent colour contrast give no reason for complaint.Besides, an ambient
light sensor dynamically adjusts brightness on the fly for glare-free visuals.
High-definition videos are
displayed without any loss in detail, while the touchscreen is responsive to
taps and swipes. Interestingly , this handset is almost as large as the Pixel 2
XL, but carries a 5.3-inch screen as opposed to the six-inch display on the
latter.
FEATURES & PERFORMANCE:
The Nokia 8 runs Android
Nougat with very little customisations. But you still get basic gesture and
motion actions: Flip the phone to reject an incoming call, “mute on pickup“,
launch the camera app when the power button is pressed twice, etc. The OS lets
you switch between apps with a double tap of the recent apps button; gives you
the ability to split the screen to view two apps at the same time and more.
The handset houses the
current flagship processor from Qualcomm, and it is no surprise that it blazed
through all synthetic benchmark tests. In fact, it fared a shade better than
the Pixel 2 XL that costs twice as much.Indeed, this smartphone is
well-equipped to handle heavy workloads, including video editing, 3D games like
Asphalt 8 and Modern Combat 5 and hi-def video content.
Nokia says this handset has
a copper cooling pipe and a graphite shield under its back panel to dissipate
heat.During tests, we did not see this construct do anything extraordinary . If
anything, we felt a fair amount of heat being generated while using the camera.
But this did not create any issues, especially since temperatures go back to
normal once the camera app is closed.
For audio, you get a single
speaker on the handset's bottom edge. This is loud and clear enough to
understand movie dialogues and to answer hands-free calls at home.Output over
earphones, however, is very good. The default sound signature is balanced, with
deep bass, as well as clear mids and highs. Calls on the Nokia 8 are clear and
the antennas do a good job of latching onto networks, even in areas of poor
coverage.
CAMERAS:
The dual rear cameras--one
with a colour and the other with a monochrome sensor--come with top-of-the-line
Zeiss lens. Both shooters work in tandem, along with an IR focus assist, to
capture snapshots. Photos taken in well-lit environs contain lots of detail
with neutral colours, which are worthy of postcard-sized prints. But this
mostly works with still subjects: There is a slight lag in focusing and shutter
release, which sometimes results in missed moments and blurry shots.
Interestingly, we didn't notice any real improvements in image quality when we
used both cameras. The only time, the stereo cameras make a difference is in
the Live Bokeh mode. Here, the Nokia 8 lets you adjust the level of background
blur for DSLR-like results. You are also given the option to focus on
background objects in the scene with the Bokeh Editor. This works well for
portrait shots, but at times it does not do a perfect job of isolating the
foreground from the background.
The camera app also
supports modes like manual control, macro, panorama, beautify , and “Dual
Sight“.The last of these lets you shoot single split-screen photos or videos
with the rear and front snappers simultaneously .The app also allows you to
livestream this footage on your Facebook and YouTube accounts.
Another interesting feature
is Nokia's home-grown Ozo audio technology , which uses the device's three mics
to record surround sound for a spatial sound effect. This works as advertised
and puts you at the centre of the action when you listen to the playback
through headphones. On the downside, this is a video-only feature.
The Nokia 8's 13MP front
camera is equipped with a wide-angle lens and beauty mode. This allows for
group shots and selfies that comprise a fair amount of detail.
BATTERY:
And finally , you can
expect to get a day's worth of mixed use internet, movies and music from the
Nokia 8. Battery life tends to drop with extended use of the camera. But you
can use its fast charger to replenish the battery to 50% in half an hour.
SPECS: 5.3-inch IPS
(2560x1440px) QHD Gorilla Glass 5 display | 2.4GHz Snapdragon 835 octa-core
processor | 4GB RAM | 64GB storage, hybrid microSD slot | 13MP (colour, OIS) +
13MP (mono) rear camera, 13MP front camera | Dual SIM | 3090mAh battery
PRICE: `36,999 | RATING:
6.5/10
GOOGLE PIXEL 2 XL
The Google Pixel 2's camera
is the best you can get on a smartphone today. Plus, the device boasts of close
integration with Google's services like Daydream for VR, Google Lens for object
recognition in search, and also, you're promised OS updates for the next couple
of years.
If price is not a
deterrent, then this handset is well worth your consideration. As alternatives,
in the same price band, you might want to consider the Samsung Galaxy Note 8 if
you want an Android device, or the Apple iPhone 8, 8 Plus, or the iPhone X that
runs the iOS operating system.
BUILD & DESIGN:
The Google Pixel 2 XL
sports an aluminium unibody design with a distinctive dual-tone finish on the
back. The camera area is polished and shiny , while the rest of the panel
with its fingerprint sensor has a matte finish for a better grip.
On the front, you get a
6-inch Gorilla Glass 5 display that's surrounded by a narrow bezel area, which
houses the handset's dual front-facing speakers.
The Pixel 2 XL lacks a home
screen button, and instead uses an onscreen control for navigation. Buildwise,
you are promised a dustproof and waterproof handset (up to a depth of one
metre) that carries an IP67 rating. Overall, the device looks and feels
premium.
TOUCHSCREEN DISPLAY:
The Pixel 2's six-inch
display is bright, and renders natural colours with excellent contrast. You get
an option to change this colour profile to “Vivid“, if you prefer a more
saturated output. There is a slight shift in colours when viewed at an angle. But
this is not a deal breaker. More importantly , because screen legibility is not
affected at all, even in sunlight.
Other configurable options
include an always-on display for time and a night mode that you can schedule to
cut screen glare when you use the handset to read.
The screen resolution does
not follow the conventional 16:9 (cinematic) aspect ratio; it is 18:9, so it
plays Full HD videos with black strips on either side. However, you can
pinch-to-zoom videos to make them fit the screen. The slim bezel, coupled with
this mode, makes movie watching enjoyable. Colours appear natural and with deep
blacks. As expected, the screen is also very responsive to touches and swipes.
FEATURES & PERFORMANCE:
The Pixel 2 comes with a
new feature called Active Edge. This lets you squeeze the handset to activate
Google Assistant. We found this to be faster and more intuitive than saying “Ok
Google“.You can configure pressure sensitivity to your preferences and even set
it to silence incoming calls. You also get motion gestures to launch the camera
and the option to use the fingerprint sensor to view the notifications panel.
Another new feature of the
Pixel 2 is its ability to listen to and identify tunes that are being played
around you; it displays the name of the track on the lock screen, and works
consistently to help you discover new music.
The Pixel 2 runs the latest
Android Oreo (v8) OS, which gives you a few new features over Nougat (v7).Some
changes shorter boot time, background tasks management and enhanced security
to protect against unsafe apps are not apparent. But there are some useful
additions like autofill for common text fields like email and usernames, and
also auto-connect to saved Wi-Fi hotspots even if you forget to switch it back
on.
Then there's Google Lens,
which can be accessed in Photos. It analyses images to provide web results of
similar-looking objects. You can use this feature to identify products,
landmarks, and even pick out text from business cards and printouts.
The handset also performs
smoothly while rendering 3D games and playing high-definition content;
multitasking between them doesn't pose any problems either.The front-facing
speakers work well for movies. Dialogues sound clear and there's even a hint of
bass without any audible distortion.
Notably , the Pixel 2 XL
does not support the standard 3.5mm headphoneearphone jack. It does not come
with a pair of USB Type-C earphones either. Instead, you get an adapter in the
box that allows you to use your existing pair. On the brighter side, you can
expect clear sound output across the aural spectrum with just the right amount
of bass. Overall call quality was found to be clear and we did not encounter
any issues with network reception either.
CAMERA:
The rear camera on the
Pixel 2 is the best we have seen so far. It captures fine details, with just
the right amount of exposure, even in incandescent lighting.Shots taken in
poorly-lit environs are also impressive.The Pixel 2 adjusts exposure well and
its HDR mode is capable of evenly-lit snapshots.
You get a portrait mode for
both snappers that uses software optimisation to blur the background. This also
works as advertised, to create a fine DSLR-like effect.
You can also take photos
and capture a few seconds of video with each shot. This feature, called Motion
Photos, saves these results in video format, in case you want to share it with
friends.
You don't get granular
control over the camera's settings. There's just exposure and white balance to
tinker around with. And you only get a few shooting modes like panorama,
photosphere and slow motion.That said, the Pixel 2 cameras easily win over all
other shooters that we've seen in current-gen handsets.
BATTERY:
We were able to get well
over a day's worth of basic usage movies, audio streaming, emails and
messaging on a single charge of its battery . With its fast charger and
fifteen minutes, you can easily extend battery life by a couple of hours.
SPECS: 6-inch pOLED
(2880x1440px) QHD+ Gorilla Glass 5 display | 2.4GHz Snapdragon 835 octa-core
processor | 4GB RAM | 64GB128GB storage | 12MP rear (OIS), 8MP front camera |
Single SIM | 3520mAh battery
PRICE: `73,000 (64GB),
`82,000 (128GB) | RATING: 6.510 Note: For this review, we tried out the Pixel 2
XL. If you want a smaller handset, you could look at Pixel 2 that comes with a
5-inch Full HD display. (`61,000 for 64GB, `71,000 for 128GB).
What the ratings mean:
Below 5: The product is poor and doesn't offer the experience it promises | 5
& 6: The product works as advertised | 7: The product is very good; will
not disappoint the buyer | 8: Very good; super value for money | 9: The device
is exceptional | 10: You're kidding, right?
TOI4 NOV17
No comments:
Post a Comment