When East Is West
Indians
heading to the West are being seduced by the inexpensive charms of Eastern
Europe
The hot new destination
for a certain kind of Indian traveller is Croatia. The boom in Indian tourists
has surprised the Croats who are generally unsurprised by a flow of new
arrivals. Ever since Croatia became one of the locations for the TV show Game
of Thrones, tourists from all over the world have flocked to its sights and the
Croats, who were noted for the disgusting quality of their hotels and their
restaurants, have suddenly had to get their act together.
But what intrigues Croats
about Indian tourists is that they don’t appear to be Game of Thrones fans.
Mention Khaleesi and they look uncomprehending. Talk about the King’s Landing
scenes shot in the Croatian city of Dubrovnik and they have no clue what you
are referring to.
So why are so many
Indians going to Croatia? Well, the short answer appears to be that, like the
Japanese, we travel in herds. Once a destination becomes popular, hordes of
Indians will descend upon it.
There was a time when
Indians loved Switzerland. Perhaps this was because of all the Yash Chopra
movies shot there. For whatever reason, the Swiss town of Interlaken, once a
favourite of European visitors, has now turned into Bollywood-on-the-Alps and
is packed out with restaurants that serve vegetarian Indian food.
Indian tourists still go
to Switzerland but I suspect that Interlaken’s moment has passed. For one
thing, most people who want to go there have already been. And for another,
Switzerland is one of the world’s most expensive destinations. It is a long way
to go and you need to spend a hell of a lot of money just to see a few snow-covered
mountains.
So Indians have looked
for fresh destinations. And the newly emerging destinations of Eastern Europe
have emerged as the obvious alternatives to Lucerne, Geneva and Interlaken.
They seem totally European and yet, most of them are one half of the price of
Switzerland or Austria. So visitors to say, Vienna (hideously expensive), will
only spend a day there before going on to Prague (much cheaper) and then
perhaps to Budapest (even cheaper than Prague!). That way, tourists can feel
they have done Europe without having to pay Western European prices.
Hence, the sudden
affection for Croatia among people who have never heard of the Lannisters and
the sudden rise in interest in such cities as Prague. And the newfound
affection for Budapest, which, I suspect, may well be the next big thing.
Budapest gets fewer
Indian tourists than other Eastern European destinations but this will change
over the next few years as prices rise in the already overcrowded Croatian
market.
For people of my
generation, however, it is hard to think of Eastern Europe outside of the
context of the Warsaw Pact. After the Second World War, nearly all of Eastern
Europe fell under the Soviet sphere of influence (defined by the Warsaw Pact)
and new countries (like Yugoslavia) were created, with the encouragement
of Moscow. While Western
Europe prospered, the Soviet bloc countries of Eastern Europe became grey,
boring places run by repressive regimes who mostly drew their authority from
the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
From 1945 to about the
start of this century, the only people who bothered to visit Eastern Europe
were tourists from other Soviet bloc countries.
After the collapse of the
Soviet bloc, Yugoslavia turned into a war zone and broke up and the other
countries also faced crises of their own. So there really was no point in
visiting any of them.
But the terrible
oppression of the Communist era and the chaos that followed blinded many of us
in India to the pre World War II history of Eastern Europe. Till the Russians
arrived and broke the souls of their populations, these countries were not very
different from their counterparts in Western Europe. Prague may not be as
beautiful as Vienna but the architecture is not very different.
As for Budapest, it was
once part of the great Austro Hungarian empire and was renowned for its beauty.
The stunning Danube river that separates the city’s two parts, Buda and Pest,
and some spectacular buildings are justly famous.
The Soviets could not
destroy the architecture but they committed various acts of vandalism,
including placing a Communist star on top of the old parliament building so
that it became the tallest building in the city (if you included the height of
the star!). They also disfigured lovely, stately parts of old Budapest with
enormous statues of murderous despots like Joseph Stalin.
When I went to Budapest a
few months ago, I was reminded of how different history could have been. The
Hungarians, proud people that they are, have suffered under a succession of
foreign rulers. They were part of the (Turkish) Ottoman empire. Then they
suffered Teutonic imperialism as the Austrian empire took over. During the
Second World War, the Nazis arrived. And after 1945, the Soviet took charge.
But there was one moment
when history could have been changed. In 1956, Hungary revolted. The Hungarians
believed (as they had been assured by the CIA) that if there was a chance of
breaking the Warsaw Pact, then America would help them. But Washington did
nothing (perhaps because it had a deal with Moscow over Suez) and the Soviets
sent their armies in to crush the uprising with great brutality. To this day,
there are buildings in Budapest that bear the scars of the Soviet shelling in
1956 and many structures still have bullet marks dating from that period.
Just as the stately
buildings in Budapest remind you of the city’s imperial past, you can’t miss
the imprint of more recent history in nearly every area. Take the hotel I
stayed at. It was opened in 1896 as the Grand Hotel Royal and was the city’s top
hotel with its own auditorium (which later became a cinema), 350 guest rooms
and a spa. Till the Second World War, it was one of Europe’s grand old hotels.
Then, the Nazis took over
Budapest and the Grand Hotel Royal became the headquarters of the Gestapo. Any
hope that it would return to its former glory once the Germans were defeated
ended when the Soviets replaced the Nazis and ran the hotel as a state
enterprise.
Despite the Soviet
control, the hotel became one of the bases for the 1956 Uprising and the
leaders of the rebellion operated from there. When the Soviet army arrived to
crush the rebellion its tanks targeted the hotel and destroyed much of the
original structure.
The hotel remained a
burnt-out shell for five years till the Communist regime decided it needed a
great hotel for state guests. The Grand Hotel was revived and enjoyed a
fleeting moment of fame before succumbing to public sectoritis again. And as
communism fell in 1991, the hotel shut its doors, its history and its grand
traditions forgotten.
It was revived in this
century by the Maltese Corinthia group (it is now called The Corinthia
Budapest), which spent millions of dollars rebuilding it. I stayed there and
was impressed by how well it was run. But it also seemed to me to be a metaphor
for Hungary and Budapest – years of glamour, followed by destruction by the
Nazis, the Soviets and other oppressors. And then finally, a glorious revival.
The rest of Budapest has
not been revived as successfully as the Grand Hotel Royal. Wages are low in
Hungary and so there is not that much money to go around. Nevertheless, there
are fancy bars, boutique hotels, Michelin-star restaurants and designer shops.
From an Indian tourist point of view, all this makes Budapest an attractive
destination because it has many of the charms of Western European cities at
half the price.
Eventually, I suspect,
fewer and fewer Indians will splash out on the great Western European
destinations (except perhaps, London). Such cities as Paris are now absurdly
expensive and, because of the language barrier, not particularly attractive to
Indian tourists. Eastern Europe with its Western European buildings and
Indian-friendly prices (hotels in Budapest are cheaper than hotels in most
Indian cities) will seem more and more alluring. Already, Hindi film producers
have begun using Hungarian locations. At first, producers passed the bridges
over the Danube off as the Parisian bridges on the Seine. But now, they are
happy to set their stories in Eastern Europe.
And as the Swiss will
tell you, it’s not Game of Thrones that decides where Indians go. It is always
Bollywood that gives the lead. And Bollywood has discovered Hungary.
HTBR11FEB18
No comments:
Post a Comment