Samsung Galaxy S8 review, 10
months later: The go-to flagship holds up well
10 months of use have treated the GS8 well
... mostly.
It's been 10 months since we published our full review of
the Galaxy S8 and S8+. In that time, several other great phones
have launched into the world, and we've compared the Galaxy S8 to all of them.
As I write this, we're less than two weeks away from the Galaxy S9 being
unveiled — and yet, the Galaxy S8 is still in the conversation. Samsung's brand
is so strong that average people are looking at buying the Galaxy S8 from
carrier stores even today — and Samsung hasn't exactly placed big discounts on
this phone to reflect its age.
But for those who read Android
Central, we know the Galaxy S8 is relatively old news. So as we get ready to see what's next, it's time to
look back on several months of using a Galaxy S8 — to see what's held up in
light of new phones and extra time using it, but also what frustrations have
stuck around and formed over time using the GS8.
THE GOOD
Samsung Galaxy S8 What I still
love
As is so often the case with modern high-end
phones, there's far more that I like than have complaints about. The Galaxy
S8's fundamentals still hold up phenomenally well as it approaches its first
birthday. It starts with the size and hardware, which is refreshing in a world
where phones are still, with a few exceptions, very large. The standard Galaxy
S8 is easily manageable in one hand even though it has a super-tall 18.5:9
aspect ratio display. It's impressively thin and light, and never feels like a chore
to hold and manipulate. I haven't even had issues with the curved sides on the
screen, which I think is a result of the phone being small enough that I'm
rarely reaching to tap anything.
The Galaxy S8 is refreshingly small, light and easy to handle. And the
hardware is beautiful.
Concerns about its fragility aside
(I'll get to those later), this is still a gorgeous phone design. The smooth
curves and perfect integration of the metal and glass are still fantastic, even
though it has come to be a bit more pedestrian as you see these out in the wild
every single day. Particularly in this black color I've been using, this is
just a classy looking device with excellent proportions and no big
distractions.
After taking a break from the
Galaxy S8 to use various other phones, one thing I appreciated upon my return
to Samsung's flagship is that it gets all of the basics right in the
hardware. 64GB of internal storage has
been plenty, and I've tossed a microSD card in there as
a backup storage option when I need it. It was a cheer-worthy moment to have a
3.5mm headphone jack again. Using wireless charging around the house — and
especially at night next to the bed — was entirely natural to come back to.
Samsung's displays still haven't been outdone. Even this 'old' panel
looks great.
And then there's the display itself. Yes it's
been outclassed by Samsung's own Galaxy Note 8 in terms of brightness and colors, but the Galaxy S8 is
still damn good nearly
a year on. It's bright enough to handle direct sunlight, but also gets dim
enough to not be harsh on your eyes late at night when you're trying to relax.
Colors are punchy, and there are no issues with off-axis viewing as you shift
the phone around. Samsung's displays have been good for so long I think we
forget just how far ahead the company is with OLED — but using other phones throughout
2017 showed how even an "old" Samsung phone is still offering one of
the best mobile displays out there.
The last part of the positive
column is the camera experience. Right off the bat I can say the Pixel 2 has
clearly jumped the Galaxy S8 in overall camera quality — from stills to HDR to
panoramas to video recording. But that doesn't mean the Galaxy S8 is bad — it's
still a great camera capable of some really good shots. I still enjoy the
punchy colors it produces, and HDR still gets the job done. Samsung's camera
app is easy to use, and I love little
tweaks like using the shutter button as a zoom slider and holding the video
recording button for a preview before capturing.
mera
sample
The Galaxy S8 just doesn't match
the Pixel 2 in every aspect, like when it comes to sharpness on edges and color
balance in very difficult scenes. Late-night photos just
aren't as good on the Galaxy S8 either. But these differences honestly only
reveal themselves when doing side-by-side tests with the Pixel 2. Right out of
the camera on their own, I like what the Galaxy S8 can do and am rarely
disappointed.
Now, the ball is back in Samsung's
court to improve with the Galaxy S9. If the
company doesn't up its game like Pixel 2 and other challengers like the Huawei Mate 10 Pro have, it will fall even further
behind.
THE ... BAD
Samsung Galaxy S8 What I don't
like
If you read my editorials here on Android
Central or follow me on Twitter, you could probably see this coming from a mile away: my least favorite
part of using the Galaxy S8 is the software and performance.
Why can't the Galaxy S8 just stay quick like the other phones on my
desk?
Roughly three months into using my
Galaxy S8 it became unbearably slow and only a
factory reset would fix it. Curiously (not really), I had the exact same issue three months
into my Galaxy Note 8 use. The second time around my GS8 has
lasted longer before the performance faded, thankfully, but I still have
hiccups and issues that I just don't expect out of a high-end phone. I'm not to
the point of wanting to go through a factory reset, but it's still frustrating
— why can't the phone just stay quick like the others on my desk?
Along the same lines, coming back
to the Galaxy S8 after some time with the Pixel 2 has reminded me how poor
battery life is on the GS8 (the GS8+, by most accounts, is good with
longevity). Doing nothing particularly intense, with less than 3 hours of
"screen on" time, my average day will get me down into 15% battery
territory before I'm even thinking about turning in for the night. Throw in any
type of music streaming, hotspotting or Android Auto use
throughout the day, and I'll most likely need a charger after dinner. A year
on, this is the weakest point of the whole "performance" experience
for me.
People can get used to anything, but the software still feels needlessly
complex in many areas.
Outside of any performance
concerns, I still feel like I have to fight the software far too often. People
can get used to anything, and over 10 months (and years of using Samsung
phones) I know my way around. But there are many tweaks, settings, pop-ups,
quirks and hidden features to get acquainted with on this phone. Sure that
means that more people will find that one thing they want, but
it comes at the cost of every Galaxy S8 owner carrying the baggage of extra
features that they don't want.
Add in the duplicate apps that
can't be uninstalled, and it's just a small layer of frustration between me and
the apps and services that I want to use. Having to update some apps through
Google Play and others through Galaxy Apps, or having weird photo quirks when
using Google Photos as your gallery app of choice, is just grating.
Also, Bixby. I have
turned off Bixby Home and disabled the Bixby button. I don't foresee coming
back to using it. Part of that is just not wanting to talk to my phone at all —
I rarely use Google Assistant either — but most of it is that every time I
tried to use Bixby it wasn't as useful as Assistant. Then there's the issue of
constantly pushing the Bixby button on accident and activating it when I didn't
want to. It's just bad, okay?
Let's wrap it up with a couple hardware
things to note. The glass on the back of my Galaxy S8 has been pretty
consistently marred by regular use. The entire bottom edge of the glass where
it meets the metal is extremely scuffed, and the top edge isn't much better.
There are a few deep marks higher up that you can easily feel. I've never dropped
this phone or treated it roughly, and a vast majority of these scratches have
formed just in the first couple months of use — because after that point, I've
gone to a super-thin case to protect it. The glass sure is beautiful and it lets Samsung
keep this phone light and also include wireless charging, but it sure doesn't
age gracefully without a case.
Also, you may have heard I'm not a
fan of Samsung's fingerprint sensor placement. It's not good, and it's still
tough to consistently reach. Samsung agrees, and seems to have remedied this by
moving the sensor below the camera(s) on the Galaxy S9. Woohoo!
RETROSPECTIVE REVIEW
Samsung Galaxy S8 10 months
later
With Samsung's position as the "go-to
flagship" for anyone who isn't buying an iPhone, the Galaxy S8 had the
goal to be more things to more people than any other phone out there. Samsung
filled it with high-end specs, tons of features and lots of software to try and
appeal to a wide swath of potential customers. And for the most part, those
pieces all held together after 10 months of use.
Samsung did well, and the Galaxy S9 has a strong foundation to build on
here.
Looking through the lens of an
early-2018 phone buyer, the Galaxy S8's hardware is still really good.
It's beautiful and easy to handle, the specs are more than capable for
modern-day tasks, the screen is still great, all of the hardware features are
appealing, and the camera is good even though it has been surpassed since it
launched.
The battery life hasn't held up
over time in light of what phones like the Pixel 2 can do with even less
capacity. The glass on the back scratches with prolonged use, just as you'd
expect. The fingerprint sensor never got any easier to use. The software isn't
the best and can slow down over time, which is perhaps the least forgivable
downside of the Galaxy S8. But those are relatively small marks on what has
been a solid phone for me and tens of millions of other people over the past 10
months. Samsung did well, and the Galaxy S9 has a strong foundation to build on
here.
ANDREW
MARTONIK
https://www.androidcentral.com/samsung-galaxy-s8-review-10-months?utm_source=ac&utm_medium=generic&utm_content=UUacUsUmU2158&utm_campaign=email
No comments:
Post a Comment