RAJIV BAJAJ UNLIKELY DISCIPLE
The
inside story of how Rajiv Bajaj’s mentoring relationship with guru Jack
Trout changed the way Bajaj Auto is run
Abook-reading session is not what you’d expect from
a CEO when his company is in the doldrums. Sometime in 2008, when Bajaj
Auto was on a sticky wicket, CEO Rajiv Bajaj, then 41, addressed his top
generals, a copy of Jack Trout’s Differentiate or Die in his hands. The
young Bajaj read out passages for a good 90 minutes, expounding the key
messages gleaned, why Bajaj Auto was floundering, and how some of Trout’s
theories could come in handy.
Finally, as Bajaj wrapped up the last chapter, Tom
Ishikawa, a Japanese executive who had joined Bajaj Auto from Yamaha, said:
“Rajiv San, all you have said is ok, but this is just a book.” Bajaj shot
back: “Tom San, Yamaha is such a big name. Even then, why isn’t it making
money?”
Five years later, Bajaj still recalls the incident.
The point being at that time, he had also been grappling with a question:
the Japanese (Sony), or Korean (LG) or Taiwanese companies, which had
mastered technology, quality, efficiency and productivity, weren’t making
money. Why? It was that cold splash of market reality, which ultimately led
Bajaj to Jack Trout, the 76-year-old author and management guru.
Since then, a fairly intense guru-shishya
relationship between Bajaj and Trout has helped the former find the answers
and transformed the way Bajaj runs the Rs 20,973 crore company. Under
Trout’s influence, Bajaj Auto has adopted a successful brand-led growth
strategy and morphed into a marketing company; j Bajaj no longer sees it as
an auto company.
Most products are sharply differentiated and enjoy
better profitability. “Our operating profit margins stand at 22%, while
that of the market leader stands at 10%, and they have nearly double our
volumes,” says Bajaj. “If I had their volumes, I would be at 25-26% profit
margins.”
In the five years since Bajaj met Trout, Bajaj
Auto’s net profit has grown almost five-fold to Rs 3,044 crore.
Though Bajaj runs a very tight ship with variable
costs on a leash and fixed and employee costs a shade under 8 per cent of
sales, he credits Trout’s contribution in shaping Bajaj Auto’s brand-led
strategy as the reason for its higher profitability. “We didn’t become
better in the kitchen, we serve better in the restaurant,” says Bajaj. Adds
Rajiv Memani, Country Managing Partner, EY India: “Under Rajiv’s
leadership, Bajaj Auto has aligned well strategically. He is very clear, he
is chasing profitability, not blind market share.”
Corporate Dossier met up with Bajaj and Trout in
Delhi last month where Bajaj and his marketing team spent a few hours
sharpening the positioning and communication strategies for the new range
of Discover motorcycles that the company is in the process of launching.
The guru was visibly pleased with his shishya. “After years of working all
over the globe, I can safely say that Rajiv is my best student,” says
Trout. “He has read my material so carefully. Sometimes, he quotes from my
books, and I ask: Did I say that?”
How the penny dropped
Three years after Rajiv Bajaj took charge, it was all smooth sailing
till the tide turned at Bajaj Auto. Its newest launch XCD, a 125cc bike
targeted at the commuter segment, bombed, sales of the Discover dipped and
overall volumes plunged. The crisis led Bajaj, a seeker and radical self
improver, to Trout’s books.
After weeks of introspection, Bajaj conceded his
company didn’t have a coherent strategy. And thus began Bajaj’s deep dive
into understanding ‘strategy’. But Bajaj was quickly disillusioned with
modern management science as the failure rate of new products still exceeded
90%. He turned to unlikely places – yoga, homeopathy and even philosophers,
like Seneca and Confucius – to glean management lessons. “The penny
dropped,” says Bajaj, when he was reading Trout’s and Steve Rivkin’s
Differentiate or Die. “I learnt almost very late that people don’t actually
buy products, they buy brands. If you take the brand out of the equation,
you reduce everything to the product level,” says Bajaj. “I didn’t
understand the true meaning of the word ‘brand’ till I read his books – and
later, met Mr Trout.”
Ever since then, Bajaj has been relentlessly
drilling Trout’s insights into the DNA of the company. Take sports bike
Pulsar, for instance. Its attributes are clear: it’s big, fast, expensive,
powerful, and its strong point is definitely not mileage. So these
attributes are made explicitly clear not only to the consumer but also to
internal functions, like R&D, marketing, sales etc.
In internal meetings at a large meeting room
adjacent to his office, Bajaj asks his top team to imagine that a Pulsar is
placed in the centre of the large oval table. All discussion always flows
within the boundaries of Pulsar attributes and brand image. Bajaj often
rejects perfectly good designs and variant proposals because they aren’t
true to the Pulsar attributes. “Great brands have to be true to their brand
promise,” says Bajaj.
“Bajaj’s competitive edge has been its consistent
focusing on ‘brands’, ‘positioning’ and creating ‘exciting segments’ for
two-wheeler enthusiasts,” agrees Sameer Lumba, Managing Director, JM
Financial Institutional Securities. Like a true student, Bajaj tests
Trout’s teachings in different situations. When flagship brand Pulsar – it
has 47% market share in the sports bike category ¬– started drawing
competition, Bajaj implemented another idea from Trout and Al Reis’ book,
Marketing Warfare. In the marketing tome, the authors advise creating a
real and perceptual benefit into the product while defending leadership.
They cite the example of Gillette defending market share by adding an extra
blade to the razor, and then, another. Bajaj adapted the insight, launching
Pulsar 200 NS with three spark plugs for better performance. Competitors
have only one or two spark plugs.
It’s a similar story in global markets, which now
account for 40% of Bajaj Auto’s sales. In Indonesia, the company was
struggling with a market share of only 2% even six years after entering the
country. Japanese heavyweights, Honda and Yamaha, and cheap Chinese brands
dominate the market.
Bajaj tied-up with Kawasaki, the Japanese
manufacturer that focused on the 400cc plus category. It also targeted the
value segment by selling the Pulsar as a Kawasaki Bajaj. “In Indonesia, we
had to find out, as Mr Trout says, a way to supply the customer with a
reason to buy. We positioned ourselves as a motorcycle specialist with a
specific technology (triple spark) vis-à-vis the Japanese, who offered a
buffet of twowheelers,” says Bajaj. “From our end, we solved the
differentiation problem and from their side (Kawasaki), we solved the
consumer access problem. So that becomes the strategy, otherwise, it is
impossible to crack the market where we are 50 years late.”
But is running a business as simple as merely
copying lessons from management books? Sure, Trout and his books did have
an influence on Bajaj, but four things set him apart – his ability to
synthesize and figure out what works for Bajaj Auto; absolute conviction in
driving ideas and actions once he has tested them; a laser-sharp focus on
motorcycles. Lastly, credit must go to his father Rahul Bajaj for rotating
him through functions. In his nearly 23 years at the company, Bajaj had
spent five years each at manufacturing, engineering and marketing before
taking the top job in April 2005.
It’s interesting that Bajaj chose to work with
Trout because he takes everything with a pinch of salt and even McKinsey
reports gather dust in his drawers. So what was it about Trout that
appealed to Bajaj? “Mr Trout’s books give principles upon which to reflect.
Unfortunately, there is no first law of management, like the first law of
thermodynamics….sometimes, there are seven new hats or seven habits or blue
ocean or bottom of the pyramid. But you can reflect on the principles he
propounds for weeks, months,” says Bajaj.
One of Bajaj’s most controversial decisions has
been to exit and stay out of scooters, a category that’s now growing at 20
per cent, and more importantly, was his father Rahul Bajaj’s heritage.
“Great brands are built on the foundation of sacrifices,” says Rajiv Bajaj.
“Making more scooters doesn’t mean making more money. We are a specialist
motorcycle company; we won’t venture out of that easily.” Trout backs
Bajaj’s bold call to stay out of scooters. “The scooter business is a bit
of a jungle with amazingly tough brands and pricing pressure. I think Rajiv
made the right call there,” he says.
And where does Trout fit in Bajaj’s fourwheeler
strategy? According to the CEO, it’s another ploy to defend leadership in
the three-wheeler category where they are global leaders. His logic: If we
can add a second or third spark plug to Pulsar, why can’t we add another
wheel to the three-wheeler, thereby increasing comfort, safety and also
giving consumers a certain feeling of prestige. “The best three-wheeler is
a four-wheeler,” he says. “We want to create a new category with Bajaj RE.
Those who create categories, create long-term businesses,” says Bajaj.
Trout in choppy waters
Given the amount of ground the guru-shishya duo has covered together, surprisingly,
there are two sides to the story of how they met. Trout remembers meeting
Bajaj after a talk in Mumbai sometime in 2008. Bajaj told him that he
wanted him to work with his team. Bajaj, on the other hand, says he had
written several emails to Trout before the meeting, without any response.
Trout doesn’t remember the emails and says he hadn’t even heard about the
company until then.
Five years later, the two enjoy a relationship
that’s long crossed the confines of a consultant-CEO commercial engagement.
They share a strong personal bond. Bajaj also ensures his team members
regularly get to spend enough time with Trout. Earlier, Trout would spend
8-10 days a year with Bajaj and his managers; now it’s down to once every
quarter.
Despite the fruitful partnership, the two are yet
to crack a vexing problem – managing Bajaj, the family brand. It has been
extended into too many products, says Trout. He even met with the Bajaj
board and family members advising them to rebrand all other Bajaj businesses.
“Gentlemen, this is a mistake, I told them. But they wouldn’t let go,”
recalls Trout. “The more successful the motorcycle brand gets, the more
Bajaj will become a motorcycle brand. Why do you want a motorcycle brand on
your electrical appliances or insurance products or sugar?”
Bajaj too is vocal about his views on this. “If I
tell you I want to show you a Bajaj product outside, you wouldn’t know what
I would show you — a hair oil, a mixer grinder or a financial product.” But
Bajaj enjoys a good challenge. “Einstein said that he derived less
satisfaction from E=MC2 than from thinking about the problem,” he says. “Mr
Trout’s biggest contribution would be that he has taught us how to think
through problems.”
Trout knows Bajaj and his brash ways all too well.
He recently presented Bajaj with a signed copy of his book Big Brand, Big
Trouble. This is what he wrote as he signed: “Rajiv, make sure to stay out
of trouble.”
Vinod Mahanta and Moinak Mitra b
y Vinod Mahanta and Moinak Mitra
CDET131206
|
No comments:
Post a Comment