TECH REVIEW TOP
DOGS
Android flagship handsets from HTC, Sony and LG
HTC Butterfly
Look & Feel: HTC makes good-looking Android phones, and the
Butterfly is no different. The handset’s unibody shell, fabricated out of
tough plastic, is coated with soft rubber, giving the device a premium
finish. Another highlight is the addition of a notification LED near the
front camera that lights up to inform users of any new message, email, or
social network post.
Interface: The phone uses HTC’s proprietary Sense user interface
which is defined by colourful icons, elaborate animations and fancy
widgets. Still, we prefer stock Android’s clean, straight lines, which look
sharper and modern. The Sense UI just seems bloated.
Screen: Its FullHD display is one of the best we’ve seen. It is
bright, displays vibrant colours and text looks crisp. Indeed, it’s a
screen made for videos.
Camera: The 8MP primary camera shoots photos that are detailed and
have accurate colours. In low-light conditions, Butterfly shoots images
that are better than what most smartphones manage. Still, white balance
seems a bit off, and images are not as sharp as we’ve seen in other premium
handsets
like the iPhone 5 or Galaxy S III.
Performance: The top-notch hardware purring under its hood makes
Butterfly a very fast phone. Apps install in seconds, web browsing is
spiffy, and demanding games like Beach Buggy run smoothly. Scrolling and
gestures like pinch-to-zoom work without a hitch. Butterfly is a capable
multimedia device and can play FullHD videos in popular formats like MP4
with ease.
Music: The music player in Butterfly integrates TuneIn Radio and
SoundHound, an app that can identify a song based on its tune. It also
features HTC’s Beats audio technology, but this does not augment sound
quality; it just increases the volume.
GPS & Maps:
GPS is fast and accurate. It locks on to satellite signals within
seconds and maintains the connection. Google Navigation and Maps experience
is fantastic on the phone. This also holds true for Google Now, a virtual
assistant that uses geo-location data to push information to users.
Battery: With typical smartphone usage, the battery lasts little
over 10 hours, which is poor. The phone comes with a battery saver mode.
When we used the phone in this mode, the battery lasted for a little over
12 hours.
Price: Butterfly has the (dubious) distinction of being an Android
phone that is more expensive than iPhone 5 in India. In simple words, it is
overpriced for what it does.
Verdict: HTC Butterfly is a fantastic smartphone and easily one of
the best we have ever used. If you care for premium feel, design and a
fantastic screen, this is it. It is a delight to use and will not
disappoint you. But the Butterfly does not offer the best value for money
in India’s existing smartphone market.
Specs: 5-inch S-LCD3 touchscreen (1920x1080 px) | 1.5GHz
quad-core processor | 2GB RAM | 16GB internal memory, microSD up to 32GB |
8MP rear camera with 1080p FullHD video | 2.1MP front camera with 1080p
FullHD video | 3G, Wi-Fi, BT 4, microUSB | 2020 mAh battery, 12 hours of
average use | Android 4.1 Jelly Bean
Price: Rs.45,900
LG Optimus G
Look & Feel: The Optimus G is a beautiful handset, sporting a
unibody design with curved edges and a glass back. Its build quality makes
it feel premium. On the down side, the phone has a tendency to heat up at
the slightest of tasks; it was most noticeable during long phone
conversations, where we could feel the heat against our ear. It’s not a
deal-breaker, but still irksome.
Camera: Low-light photos are plagued with noise, and images don’t
have great detail in daylight either. Still, the Optimus G has a few neat
tricks like the ‘CheeseShutter’ which takes a photo when you say cheese;
but what’s the point if the photo itself isn’t of great quality? In fact,
it works better for recording video, especially with its clear audio
capture.
Interface: LG has introduced quite a few custom elements to Android
Jelly Bean that enhance the interface. The QuickMemo, for instance, turns
any screen into a screenshot on which you can quickly take notes. On the
other hand, LG has enforced restrictions on users; something we have never
seen before. For example, once the phone reaches a certain temperature – or
when the battery is low – you can’t increase the screen’s brightness. While
this is great for those new to smartphones, it’s very limiting in actual
usage.
Screen: The high-def display is defined by bright colours and sharp
images. But spend some time with it, and issues start cropping up: Sunlight
legibility is a big issue, and since brightness can’t be increased, it only
becomes worse. Also, there is noticeable banding – a lack of smooth
gradation in colour.
Performance: The Optimus G works like a charm, whether it was
playing high-def games, multi-tasking between several apps, or even
watching FullHD movies.
Music: It has very good audio output with a deep, thumping bass.
Part of the credit should go to the superb packaged headphones – apart from
their sound quality, they sport a nice design with a rubber cable that
seems like it will last for a long time.
GPS & Maps: There’s nothing great, nor bad when it comes to the
Optimus G’s GPS and mapping solutions. It uses Google Maps and just works.
Battery: The Optimus G includes two power-saving options: Power
Saver (which turns off Wi-Fi, lowers screen brightness, turns off vibrate,
etc) and Eco Mode (which optimises CPU for efficiency). And these are needed,
considering the phone lasts just 14 hours on average use. A little
disappointing for its price tag.
Price: While the MRP is 34,500, the phone is available in the market
for under 32,000 – a much fairer price for what it offers. But with the
screen’s sunlight problems and the heating issues of the handset, we don’t
think it’s worth more than competitors like the Samsung Galaxy S III.
Verdict: The LG Optimus G has a lovely design, feels premium, and
there is absolutely nothing you can fault with its performance. The camera
is a little weak, but captures video really well. But the screen’s sunlight
legibility problems, the phone’s heat issues and the lacklustre battery
life make it a tad substandard. In fact, we feel the older Optimus 4X HD (
27,000 approx) is better value for money at the moment.
Specs: 4.7-inch True HD IPS+ touchscreen (1280x768 px) | 1.5GHz
quadcore CPU | 2GB RAM | 32GB internal memory, no microSD | 13MP rear cam,
1080p FullHD video; 1.3MP front cam, 720p HD video | 3G, Wi-Fi, BT 4, microUSB
| 2100mAh battery, 14 hours avg use | Android 4.1 Jelly Bean
Price Rs.34,500
Sony Xperia Z
Look & Feel: The Xperia Z sports a minimalistic candybar design
that’s defined by clean, straight lines. It is built out of plastic, but is
covered with scratch-resistant glass, which makes it slippery to hold and a
fingerprint magnet. Still, the Z looks distinctive and classy. Those
looking for a tough device might want to consider this handset, especially
since it’s waterproof and dustproof. During our review, we dipped the
handset in some water, and we’re happy (and relieved) to report that it
passed the test.
Interface: The device uses a custom UI called Experience Flow, and
comes with a few proprietary mini apps such as voice recorder, calculator
and a notepad. So if you’re working on a document and need to do some
calculations, just hit the multitasking key, open the calculator mini-app,
and do your math; all without getting out of your office suite. Screen: The
Xperia Z sports a FullHD screen that’s capable of sharp photos and crisp
fonts. Still, all is not well with this display: viewing angles are poor
and colours lack contrast when compared to other high-end devices in this
price bracket.
Performance: Internet browsing is spiffy, the user interface is
lag-free, all sensors work well, FullHD videos play smoothly, and games run
without any compromise. But all this performance comes at a cost. Xperia Z
runs hot. Even half an hour of web browsing can make it uncomfortable to
hold.
GPS & Maps: Google Navigation, which displays traffic
information and routes, and Maps and Google Now, which are part of Android,
are fantastic services. On Xperia Z, they work well in tandem with the
device’s GPS chip that locks onto satellite signals quickly and accurately.
Music: The handset comes with Sony’s Walkman app that has a gorgeous
user interface and even plays 24-bit .flac files. The sound output through
speakers is nothing special but if you use its headphones, the audio is
crisp, rich and detailed.
Camera: Its 13MP primary shooter clicks decent photos, but its
output is not quite in the league of what other high-end phones produce.
Pictures don’t look very sharp, and the camera struggles with dynamic
range. In low or artificial light, the images are prone to noise and loss
of colour.
Battery: The Xperia Z battery life is middling at 14 hours when used
with 3G – just about enough for a work day.
Price: Despite it large screen, and dust- and water-proof exterior,
we feel that the Xperia Z is a bit overpriced at 38,990. A few thousands
lesser would make it a competitive proposition when compared to the
best-selling Samsung Galaxy Note II phablet.
Verdict: The Xperia Z is a fast and good-looking handset, which is
also dust-resistant and waterproof. But an average screen and middling
camera prevents us from giving it an outright recommendation. Pick it up if
you want a rugged, big-screen smartphone that can handle demanding games
and weather.
Specs: 5-inch BRAVIA touchscreen (1920x1080 px) | 1.5GHz
quad-core CPU | 2GB RAM | 16GB memory, microSD up to 32GB | 13MP rear cam,
1080p FullHD video | 2.2MP front camera, 1080p FullHD video | 3G, Wi-Fi, BT
4, microUSB | 2330 mAh battery, 14 hours avg use | Android 4.1 Jelly Bean
Price Rs.38, 990
|
No comments:
Post a Comment