Guru Speak
Anthony
Mayo, Director,
Leadership
Initiative, HBS
- Why some
business leaders
have a
shelf life
Empathy is a
key quality that successful business leaders need
to cultivate to stay on top, says Harvard's Anthony Mayo
Ragged Dick
isn't a book even the most voracious of bibliophiles
would have read or even heard of. Yet, when the novel was first
published in 1868, soon after the American Civil War, it went on
to become a
bestseller. It has a straight forward plot: the
protagonist,
Ragged Dick, an honorable 14-year-old boot polisher,with a few
vices (drinking, smoking etc), decides to turn a new leaf.
He rescues a
drowning boy, whose father offers him a suit and a job.
Young Ragged
Dick accepts the both gratefully, assumes a stuffy
sounding name (Richard
Hunter) and becomes respectable.
The novel was
penned by gentleman called Horatio Alger Jr who
penned 120 books which had one recurring theme: young men
working hard to find their way from rags to riches.
Basically, the American Dream.
Alger's stories served as a muse for
Anthony Mayo,
a senior lecturer at Harvard Business School (HBS)
who
specializes in leadership and business history.
“The basic
premise of the Horatio Alger stories was that anybody
with pluck,determination
and drive could be successful in America.
It is the
American dream.
We wanted to
see if it was true or not,“ says Mayo.“Unfortunately,
it's not true.“
Mayo, along
with HBS Dean Nitin Nohria, compiled the Great
American Business Leadersdatabase a
chronicle of 1000 odd leaders
of American business in the 20th century.
Everybody from Jack Welch to Sam Walton to
Bill Gates are on it.
“Guess how
many women turned up in that list?“ asks Mayo.
“Only 40, in a
list of 1000 business leaders.“ Another 40-odd were
non-white.“The elite
circle of business is a closed group.
Some argue that they have wonthe ovarian
lottery...that they have been
born into schooling at the top tier schools and they follow this path,“
says Mayo, who
has dealt with this topic at length in his book
Paths to
Power: How Insiders and Outsiders Shaped
American Business Leadership.
Are things
changing in the 21st century?
Will the list
look any different if it was compiled again 15 years
from now?
Mayo mulls over the question for a while before answering.
“In the past,
if you were not a part of the elite group,you had to
make
your fortunes by serving your own constituency.
Of the 40
women in the database, 39 women created businesses that
served other women,“ he says. But, with access to education
getting
wider, a newer set of people arelikely to
emerge as the next generation
of business leaders. “Fifteen years from now,if you look at
it
demographically, in the US, I expect a lot more people of color,
a lot
more foreign nationals and many more women to make it to the list,“
adds
Mayo.
Contextual
intelligence in leadership is another area of research for Mayo.
“When people
talk of leadership, they focus on what's in front of them,
on current
challenges. Contextual leadership is about having a
periphery
vision,“ he says.
Business
people who have contextual intelligence understand the context.
They either
seize the context and shape it for their business or learn to
adapt.“When you look
at the database of great American business leaders,
you see that
these people captured the zeitgeist of the times.
They were risk
takers and many of them failed.
Many of them
were flawed human beings but for most part they
recognized the context and were able to create business opportunities
out of
that,“ says Mayo.
Which
companies and business leaders exemplify contextual intelligence?
Mayo picks
Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook, Steve Jobs and
Apple Computers as great examples of contextual intelligence at
work.
"Steve Jobs reinvented himselfover time. He
wasn't successful in his first
run as CEO but adapted himself and eventually succeeded in the role
(in his second stint
at Apple),“ says Mayo. On the other end of the
spectrum is eBay,
which pioneered the e-commerce business but has
since struggled.
Meanwhile,
upstarts like Jack Ma's Alibaba have done remarkable things
in that space.
So, do
business leaders, like the products, have a shelf life, given that
context
constantly keeps
changing?
“Success can be a double edged sword. Sometimes business leaders
can
get arrogant about their way of operating,
and if they think that there's
only one way to do things,
then eventually the context will change and
they will become irrelevant,“
saysMayo, who
believes empathy is a
quality business leaders need to work on.
“Research
shows that the higher up somebody, the lesser empathy they
have,“explains Mayo.
Why is that the case?
Partly because they aren't creating a context where they get honest
feedback.
Business
leaders start believing in their own myths and feel that they
don't need to
look at somebody
else's point of view.
“When you are
on top, you find that people tell you what you want
to hear. It is important
that you have trusted allies who will tell you
things you don't want to hear. Sometimes
that's painful,“ he says.
|
tv
mahalingam
|
CDET
6FEB15
No comments:
Post a Comment